I also voted "other" and Magicwand summed it up very well. Of course I only "judge" people by their rank in Go (any other fields are mostly irrelevant to Go rank), and even then all I ever judge (using that word lightly, perhaps "consider" is a better term) is the validity/accuracy of their advice. Like Magicwand said, we can always learn from another player's reasoning.

_________________
All About Go | Go website featuring lessons, history of Go, downloads, articles by professionals and more.