Life In 19x19
http://lifein19x19.com/

Tips for reviewing my own games
http://lifein19x19.com/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=13151
Page 1 of 1

Author:  Kap [ Mon May 02, 2016 2:11 pm ]
Post subject:  Tips for reviewing my own games

Hi all,

I've picked up Go in the wake of the match between Lee Sedol and AlphaGo and have played some dozen games online since then. Initially I wouldn't give my finished games much thought but over the last couple days I experienced a growing desire to review my games on a real goban.

However, unless it's a life and death situation I can try to read out I don't seem to be getting as much out of reviewing as I had hoped (other than a tired arm from placing hundreds of stones in relatively quick succession :lol:).

Any tips on how I should go about reviewing my own games? Is there a list of questions I should ask myself before/after every move? Should I go over the game multiple times focusing on a different aspect each time? If so, what aspects?

Any and all help is much appreciated.

- Kap

Author:  EdLee [ Mon May 02, 2016 2:26 pm ]
Post subject: 

Hi Kap,

One question you can try is find the game losing move.
It's not always possible, of course.
Sometimes, we need a higher level person to help us.
But you can try. :)
Self-review is nice, but please also bare in mind,
for some (not all) beginners, your reading and thought process
for each move can veer off quite quickly.
Example: if you spend 5 minutes pondering a move,
maybe the first 20-30 seconds, your reading is still 'reasonable';
but beyond that, it's mostly unreasonable. Of course, this is not true for everyone, but from my anecdotal experience with beginners,
this happens quite often. The net result is you waste 4.5 out of the 5 minutes.
On every move. Or many of the moves.
A very inefficient use of your time.
A much more efficient way is to think about it (but not so much time),
and find a (much) higher level person to help.
Again, this is not always possible.

For example, if you post a recent, 'serious' game here for review
(or any other venues), you may be surprised by your blind spots
that the reviewer(s) help point out for you.

It takes some experience, work, trial-and-error, and sometimes a good friend (teacher) to help us realize just how much (or little) we actually know. :)

See also DK effect.

Author:  Bill Spight [ Mon May 02, 2016 2:28 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Tips for reviewing my own games

Reviewing your own games can be a challenge, because it is hard to see your own blind spots. However, you will see some bad moves and problematic ones yourself, especially at your level. For one thing, you are making a lot of bad moves. ;) For another, you are advancing rapidly. :)

Tip #1) Try to find the losing move.

Tip #2) Play variations on the board. (Edit: OIC that you are doing that. Playing variations on a computer is less taxing on your arm. You can also save the variations for later reference. :))

Tip #3) Play against stronger players, preferably at least 5 stones stronger. Even if they do not offer a review, they will punish many of your mistakes.

Good luck! :)

Author:  xed_over [ Mon May 02, 2016 3:03 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Tips for reviewing my own games

Yeah, its not necessary to review every move.
Looks for you're most common or frequent mistake. Focus on correcting that in your next game(s).
Then start looking for your next most frequent mistake, and so on :)

As Ed says, looking for you losing move can be fun. Especially in close games. (lost by 0.5 points): "Surely I could found one point some where!?"

Author:  Kap [ Mon May 02, 2016 4:01 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Tips for reviewing my own games

Thank you for your responses. I will definitely try to identify the losing move from now on (for both me and my opponent in the case of a win).

@EdLee I can definitely see that pondering as a beginner has diminishing returns. Thanks for pointing it out. My most recent serious game is
I still don't know why I didn't invade the bottom right corner... or anywhere on the right side really.


@Bill I will try to play stronger opponents more often. So far I have focussed on getting even games. The benefits are evident but I'm a little afraid I might become frustrated rather quickly. Only one way to find out.

@xed_over Identifying this most frequent mistake is easier said than done ;-). Also 0.5 point games are close to being a myth for us beginners. Usually some group dies off and the point difference jumps up, leading to large discrepancies even after close games.

- Kap

Attachments:
File comment: My most recent serious game
recent_game.sgf [1.44 KiB]
Downloaded 652 times

Author:  Bill Spight [ Mon May 02, 2016 4:23 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Tips for reviewing my own games

Kap wrote:
@Bill I will try to play stronger opponents more often. So far I have focussed on getting even games. The benefits are evident but I'm a little afraid I might become frustrated rather quickly. Only one way to find out.


Take a proper handicap, so that you win about half the time. That is not so frustrating. :)

Author:  EdLee [ Mon May 02, 2016 5:24 pm ]
Post subject: 

Hi Kap,

Before :b23: , you played well.

:b23: This feels a bit cramped. ( Either G3 or G4 seems better. )

:b25: Similar problems as :b23: . E3 or E4 is bigger.

:b27: Much better.

:b35: Similar problems as :b23: , :b25: -- slow.

:b39: Wrong shape: you let W atari for free for no good reason.
Just M14.

:w42: At least M13.

:b53: Can take more; J9.

:b55: You probably didn't read what if W ataris twice at D18, E18,
then ataris B18 ?

:b61: H17.

:b77: Find a better move and sequence.

Author:  Bill Spight [ Mon May 02, 2016 8:33 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Tips for reviewing my own games

A couple of comments. :)



Main focus: Faint heart ne'er won fair lady.

Author:  Kap [ Tue May 03, 2016 12:08 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Tips for reviewing my own games

Thank you very much for your time and effort!

Would you say that my biggest problem right now is timid play? Not making bigger jumps for fear of being cut, not challenging white's group as Bill showed, being too busy protecting my cutting point to notice :b77: at H17 capturing the 2 white stones (and thus the whole group? I don't see a way for white to live after H17), etc.

@EdLee You are right, I was oblivious to the sequence you showed starting from :b55:, thank you.

- Kap

Author:  EdLee [ Tue May 03, 2016 12:10 am ]
Post subject: 

Kap wrote:
being too busy protecting my cutting point to notice Black 77 at H17 capturing the 2 white stones (and thus the whole group?
Hi Kap,

Liberties. Awareness of liberties. Seeing ataris is part of it.

Basics. Knowledge of the basics: basic shapes, basic tesujis, basic life-and-death, basic contact fights, etc.

If you have the time and access to basic Go problems, start doing them as soon as you can,
and as often as you can afford to. :)

Author:  EdLee [ Tue May 03, 2016 12:23 am ]
Post subject: 

Hi Kap,

Regarding your question about your 'biggest' problem(s),
these are some of the areas that most of us (amateurs) are working on,
regardless of our levels:
- reading;
- small, slow moves (what you may say 'timid' moves);
- too fast/thin, overplays;
- all the basics (re: previous post).
- etc.

Suppose you make a move that's considered small or slow later in the review.
Well, there could be multiple reasons for you playing it.
Examples:
- there're no weak groups on the board, everything is OK; there are still big points left unclaimed, and you miss one (or more);
- your opponent has a weak group you should attack, but you don't notice it;
- you have a weak group but you don't notice it;
- there's a very nice sequence or tesuji that could gain you a lot, but you don't see it.
- etc.

You also mention fear of cuts. Again, this has multiple aspects.
Examples: knowledge of basic shapes; evaluation of current situation, etc.

See, it's all related. Our mistakes are the 'symptoms'; they reveal gaps in our Go knowledge.
Of course, each person's particular strengths and weaknesses are unique.
Generally, for your levels, it's the issues in the previous post.
For example, there's no one-size-fit-all magic pill (or solution)
to fix ALL your small, slow, timid moves. :)

Author:  Kap [ Tue May 03, 2016 1:18 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Tips for reviewing my own games

Thank you again for your time.

It's healthy to never assume the existence of a one-size-fit-all solution for anything ;-)
If one existed in the context of Go then surely this game wouldn't be as attractive a hobby/object of study.

I'm currently working through The Second Book of Go to improve my grasp on the basics and solving problems from the Graded Go Problems for Beginners series when at home and if time permits. I have bound the elementary problems of Cho Chikun's Encyclopedia into an A6 booklet for train rides/downtimes at the job.

I thought of self-reviewing as a nice addition to my study regimen and am certainly not expecting it to fix all my problems :)

- Kap

Author:  EdLee [ Tue May 03, 2016 1:40 am ]
Post subject: 

Hi Kap,

Those are good books. Good that you're studying them. :)

Author:  Bill Spight [ Tue May 03, 2016 1:53 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Tips for reviewing my own games

Kap wrote:
Would you say that my biggest problem right now is timid play? Not making bigger jumps for fear of being cut, not challenging white's group as Bill showed, being too busy protecting my cutting point to notice :b77: at H17 capturing the 2 white stones (and thus the whole group? I don't see a way for white to live after H17), etc.


I didn't see play that I would call timid. :) But you could have been more enterprising. Consider :b25:. I trust that now you see that it would have been better at :b27:, approaching the White stone in the corner while extending Black's position on the bottom side. :b25: is not timid, but it is unenterprising. In the center :b85: threatens the cut at H-09, but in the end you never make that cut. Can White live if you cut at H-09? That is for him to prove. :)

Author:  daal [ Tue May 03, 2016 2:32 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Tips for reviewing my own games

One way of focusing on just a few mistakes is to review your games backwards. (Considerably easier on a computer). By starting at the end of the game, it's often clear what went wrong for you (I let that territory get too big, I let these stones get captured, etc.) and then you can move back through the game until you get to the spot where that event began and think about what you might have done differently.

Author:  Kap [ Tue May 03, 2016 6:06 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Tips for reviewing my own games

Quote:
In the center :b85: threatens the cut at H-09, but in the end you never make that cut.

This cut is super obvious now but during the game it never even crossed my mind :oops:

@daal Thank you, that's a fantastic idea! It's something I haven't tried before but definitely will incorporate into my future reviews.

- Kap

Author:  Bill Spight [ Tue May 03, 2016 7:37 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Tips for reviewing my own games

Kap wrote:
@daal Thank you, that's a fantastic idea!


Yes, it is, isn't it? :D

Quote:
Quote:
In the center :b85: threatens the cut at H-09, but in the end you never make that cut.

This cut is super obvious now but during the game it never even crossed my mind.


One of the nice things about being at your level is how quickly you learn. One day you never see something, the next day it's super obvious. :)

Page 1 of 1 All times are UTC - 8 hours [ DST ]
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/