Page 2 of 2

Re: Who Comes In Second In the US Open

Posted: Tue Aug 10, 2010 6:51 am
by topazg
Europe does now have people entering (and having their entrance accepted) as 8 dan, so I think it is fair to say now that there are European 8 dans.

Re: Who Comes In Second In the US Open

Posted: Tue Aug 10, 2010 7:14 am
by averell
topazg wrote:Europe does now have people entering (and having their entrance accepted) as 8 dan, so I think it is fair to say now that there are European 8 dans.

Maybe ask the people if they entered as 8dan, or were entered as 8dan by the organizers. Cause i've heard
of the latter. Of course for your point it doesn't make a difference.

Re: Who Comes In Second In the US Open

Posted: Tue Aug 10, 2010 10:28 am
by xed_over
there was a whole discussion about this on the old GoDiscussions forum, which we no longer have access to, and that discussion may have partially influenced the AGA decision for capping amateur ranks at 7d.

I agree with the decision.

Re: Who Comes In Second In the US Open

Posted: Tue Aug 10, 2010 11:01 am
by hyperpape
Horibe wrote:You are correct it is "convenient" but it is just as convenient if precision is needed to say "Andy Liu 8.7"


I find it inconvenient when you're generalizing or when context is lacking. I.E. "The group of 9.0s is very elite."

Re: Who Comes In Second In the US Open

Posted: Tue Aug 10, 2010 11:06 am
by Horibe
hyperpape wrote:
I find it inconvenient when you're generalizing or when context is lacking. I.E. "The group of 9.0s is very elite."


I simply do not understand. It is easy to say - "The AGA has a large number of players ranked 7 dan. Those with ratings above 8.0 are very elite".

Re: Who Comes In Second In the US Open

Posted: Tue Aug 10, 2010 12:04 pm
by Javaness
So who is this Francis Meyer fellow?

Re: Who Comes In Second In the US Open

Posted: Tue Aug 10, 2010 12:33 pm
by xed_over
Javaness wrote:So who is this Francis Meyer fellow?

from Round 3, board 1:
USGO1 [-]: Francis Meyer is a US born player. He was born in North Carolina and raised in Osaka, Japan.
USGO1 [-]: He was an insei at the Kansai Kiin, mentored by Maeda Ryo 6p.
USGO1 [-]: He's 19 years old, and 2-0 so far in this US Open.
USGO1 [-]: Yesterday Francis defeated Shiyao Qiao, a Chinese 1p from Shanghai.
USGO1 [-]: Francis has moved to the US as well now, to attend university. To Colorado, in fact.