Life In 19x19

How does it fail in differentiating Atsusa and Atsusi?

jlt wrote:in the game of go, what is the difference between atsumi and atsusa?

ChatGPT wrote:I'm sorry, but I am not familiar with the terms "atsumi" and "atsusa" in the context of the game of Go. In Go, players take turns placing black and white stones on a grid-shaped board, with the aim of surrounding and capturing their opponent's pieces and territory. I am not aware of any special terms or concepts in the game that use the words "atsumi" or "atsusa." It is possible that these terms may be specific to a certain variant or style of Go, or may have been coined by a particular player or school of thought, but without more information, I cannot provide any further information.

Since we really seem to be talking about ChatGPT generating go related text, how about this?

Sure, here is a possible Shakespearean style sonnet in iambic pentameter about a grandfather teaching his children and grandchildren to play the ancient game of go:

My granddad, master of the ancient game,
Sits with his kin and teaches them to play
The art of go, with stones of different name
And lines that mark the board in neat array.

He shares his wisdom, gained from years of play,
And guides their hands as they place stones with care,
Explaining how to make their moves each day
And win the game with skill and strategy rare.

With each new lesson, their abilities bloom
And they grow wiser in the ways of go,
Learning to think ahead and plan their moves
And outmaneuver foes with cunning blows.

My granddad's patience and guidance never cease
As he teaches his children and grandchildren the art of go.

To chatGPT, well it says it's not for advice so of course the first thing I will do is defy that. Elon Musk would be a hypocrite to object to that philosophy . . .

elomhycykushiatorwillson_mail.com Give me advice
Here are a few pieces of advice:
Don't be afraid to ask for help when you need it.
Take time to reflect on your goals and priorities.
Be kind and respectful to others.
Don't be afraid to try new things and take risks.
Take care of yourself by getting enough sleep, exercise, and nutrition.
These are just a few general pieces of advice, and what might be right for one person may not be right for another. It's always a good idea to think about what is best for you and your situation.

elomhycykushiatorwillson_mail.com What is thickness in Go?
In the game of Go, thickness refers to a group of stones (i.e., the stones of one player) that are closely positioned together and form a solid wall or block. This can be a useful strategy in the game because it makes it difficult for the opponent to attack or invade the group of stones. Additionally, thickness can also serve as a way to build territory or potential territory on the board.

It gives the option for you to give what you think the ideal response should have been. Anyone? To be fair I think thickness in Go refers to my skull when I'm playing

ChatGPT is all about (language) shape and no brain

Still quite impressive

Apparently a terrible source of information -- they warn you of that. First it completely misses the question on board dimensions (addressing number of grid points), then goes on to give a diameter for go stones about 1/4 - 1/3 their size.

What are the preferred dimensions for a go board and for go stones?

The dimensions of a go board and the size of the go stones can vary depending on the preferences of the players and the size of the playing space. However, in general, a go board should be large enough to allow for a comfortable playing experience, with enough space for the stones to be placed and moved around the board. The standard size for a go board is 19x19 lines , which is the size used in most professional and competitive games.

As for the size of the go stones, they should be small enough to be easily handled by the players and placed on the board, but not so small that they are difficult to see or pick up. The standard size for go stones is around 5mm to 7mm in diameter, although some players may prefer larger or smaller stones depending on their preference. It is important to note that the size of the go stones should be consistent throughout the game, so that the players are able to accurately gauge the size of the board and the position of the stones.

I guess in the AI world lines are their freedom units

Elom "So should there be separate pro associations or one unified pro association?"

ChatGPT "It is not necessary or advisable to have separate pro associations for baduk players from different countries. Instead, there should be a single, unified pro association that is open to all players, regardless of their nationality. This would ensure that all players have equal access to opportunities for professional advancement, and that the best players from around the world can compete against and learn from one another. A unified pro association would also help to promote the growth and popularity of baduk, and would ensure that the game is governed by a consistent set of rules and standards."

LOL I'm sorry I asked

Elom Which ruleset is the best?

ChatGPT There is no definitive answer to this question, as different rulesets for baduk can have their own strengths and weaknesses. Baduk, also known as Go, is a game that has been played for centuries, and over time, a variety of different rulesets have been developed. Some rulesets may be more popular in certain regions or among certain groups of players, while others may be less commonly used. Ultimately, the best ruleset is one that is fair, balanced, and allows for a high level of skill and strategy. It is also important for the ruleset to be well-defined and consistently applied, in order to ensure a fair and enjoyable game for all players.

All awfully Orphic.

... the word "orphic" typically refers to the religious and philosophical beliefs and practices of the ancient Greek Orphic sect, and it is not clear how this would be relevant to the text generated by a language model like myself. As a language model, I am trained to generate text that is similar to human language, but I do not have the ability to hold beliefs or practices of any kind, including those that are Orphic. I am simply a tool that can be used to provide information and answer questions based on the data that I have been trained on.

How can I build a go set with 361 identical tokens, a paintbrush, black paint, white paint and a large piece of cardboard?

ChatGPT wrote:To build a go set with 361 identical tokens, a paintbrush, black paint, white paint, and a large piece of cardboard, you will need to follow these steps:

Gather all of the materials you will need: 361 identical tokens, a paintbrush, black paint, white paint, and a large piece of cardboard.

Using the black and white paint, carefully paint the 361 tokens so that half of them are black and half of them are white. Be sure to let the paint dry completely before moving on to the next step.

Once the tokens are dry, use the large piece of cardboard to create a board for the game. You can either draw a grid of 19x19 squares on the cardboard and cut out each square to create the board, or you can use a ruler and pencil to draw the grid directly on the cardboard.

Once the board is complete, you can place the tokens on the board to play the game of go. The black tokens will be placed on the intersections of the lines on the board, and the white tokens will be placed on the empty spaces between the lines.

When playing the game, each player will take turns placing their tokens on the board, trying to surround and capture the other player's tokens. The game ends when all of the intersections on the board are filled, or when one player concedes.

Overall, building a go set with 361 identical tokens, a paintbrush, black paint, white paint, and a large piece of cardboard is a simple process that only requires a bit of time and patience. By following the steps outlined above, you should be able to create your own go set and enjoy this classic board game.

(The text above is almost normal, except for 2-3 details...)

how do you get better at go? the same way you get to carnagy hall, practice, practice, practice.

To get to Carnegie Hall, buy a ticket.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5eW6Eagr9XA

In this video, the popular scientific channel Veritasium discusses what it takes to become an expert at something. He distinguishes - allegedly based on scientific research - 4 characteristics.

1. the domain needs to lend itself to expertise, i.e. have a low degree of randomness
2. you need to spend the proverbial 10 000 hours, i.e. a lot of dedicated time
3. you need to push yourself and acquire skills in the domain you didn't previously have, aka "deliberate practice"
4. you need to get frequent, meaningful feedback on your performance, to understand if the invested effort leads to actual improvement and if not, adapt your schedule

#1 looks trivial: no one tries to become an expert at throwing dice; however, some domains present themselves as allowing for expertise, while they are essentially random, e.g the stockmarket
#2 and #3 are well documented
#4 is particularly interesting: some types of practice include immediate feedback, while others don't

Go is a competitive game, so regardless of the practice you have put in, your next match depends on the strength of your opponent. Also, it is not always easy to understand what the main issue is holding you from victory. Is it knowledge? Is it the reading ability? Is it the mental part?

One solution is to choose another success criterium than the outcome of the next matches or your rank. When you do tsumego, measure your success at that. The problem here is that eventually, most players will want to improve their overall match performance and rank, being the ultimate measure of your level of expertise. So you want to practice what matters most. But what is that?

Go in my experience also has a certain degree of randomness. You can play a good game but make one big mistake and all is lost. You can play a good game and make no big mistakes but so did the opponent and you lose by half a point. You can play a good game but felt like you needed to go into that big fight and you lost it by one liberty.

With this degree of uncertainty and the loose coupling between investment and outcome, Go is a very tough domain to become an expert at, or at least to realize why exactly you are not becoming an expert. I have been a 2 dan for 20 years now. Regardless of my investment, I keep playing as one. Is this my final plateau? Or do I have a 3-4d in me, given the right kind of practice? I find that very hard to tell.

One thing I do know is that I felt the biggest leap forward, intrinsically and also proven by a sudden rise from 2k to 2d, when I played a number of serious games in a row, without time limits, in a rivalry of sorts where we kept changing the handicap depending on the outcome, which I then replayed from memory and reviewed for myself. I also read a book at that time: Kato's killer of Go, which made a big impression on me. Reflecting on that, perhaps today's habits of playing 5+5x30 online games (i/o no time limits), reviewing thme with KataGo (i/o for myself), using the ready made sgf (i/o reconstructing the game by heart) finding patterns of mistakes and then taking these as a theme in the next batch of games (i/o more subconscious learnings), and watching youtube lectures by Michael Redmond (i/o reading a book) is more convenient than effective.

I like your text much better, than the ChatGPT text