Life In 19x19

HermanHiddema wrote:

willemien wrote:

The sad thing is that (if everything was done according to the rules that Rob van Zeijst should have set the timesettings (rule 3.6) and that both captains are responsible (it is not mentioned anywhere who they are)

Why is that sad?

if it waa Ondrej Silt who had to set the time settings he (Ondrej Silt) would have less ground to complain. (There is no ground to complain if you made the mistake yourself)

willemien wrote:

HermanHiddema wrote:

willemien wrote:

The sad thing is that (if everything was done according to the rules that Rob van Zeijst should have set the timesettings (rule 3.6) and that both captains are responsible (it is not mentioned anywhere who they are)

Why is that sad?

if it waa Ondrej Silt who had to set the time settings he (Ondrej Silt) would have less ground to complain. (There is no ground to complain if you made the mistake yourself)

If you download the game you can see that the byoyomi time setting is 25 in 10

Long story short end. Ondrej Silt accepted his loss on time. I suppose the appeals committee decision will be made public somewhere ... The appeals committee decided that the game should be continued were it stopped with the correct byoyomi settings. Both team captains agreed on this but Ondrej didn't want to continue the game, he preferred to accept the loss on time.

betterlife wrote:Long story short end. Ondrej Silt accepted his loss on time. I suppose the appeals committee decision will be made public somewhere ... The appeals committee decided that the game should be continued were it stopped with the correct byoyomi settings. Both team captains agreed on this but Ondrej didn't want to continue the game, he preferred to accept the loss on time.

I think he made the right decision. I mean, the rules clearly say that the game is a loss on time. At least that is how I see them