Page 23 of 61
Re: A beginner's journal of little interest
Posted: Thu Jul 19, 2012 8:07 pm
by Boidhre
jts wrote:At the same time, handicap fuseki is stressful, by design. Maybe others will be horrified, but I tend not to think too hard facing 2+ stones... If I obsess over how horrible and vulnerable my position is, I'll have a headache by the time I see the first mistake. (there is a strange tendency, if you look at the malko games, for observers to make "omg w is a fake Dan can't handle so much handi" kinds of comments. The position looks bad because there's a handicap, people. You can't claw back 2 stones in ten moves.)
This is true. A friend described playing against 9 stones to me as "I'm going to die everywhere," and then 100 moves later...
Re: A beginner's journal of little interest
Posted: Fri Jul 20, 2012 9:39 am
by jts
Boidhre wrote:This is true. A friend described playing against 9 stones to me as "I'm going to die everywhere," and then 100 moves later...
Yes, exactly. It is, of course, not good to play in ways that hope for mistakes from your opponents. But playing as though you were reviewing an even game, dismissing variations because they aren't good for white or leave weaknesses and looking for something better... that way lies madness.
By the way, getting up to get yourself a drink on move 5 is a good way to slow yourself down and think carefully about the fuseki.
Re: A beginner's journal of little interest
Posted: Sat Jul 21, 2012 3:20 pm
by Boidhre
Back to 11k for the moment.
Played a 7k friend, got killed all over the board. Some major blunders as per usual. I was playing too often in gote I think. I need to get more real time games in, I've played far too few and my thinking under time pressure has gotten very sloppy.
Anyway, enjoy me getting crushed.
http://lifein19x19.com/forum/download/file.php?id=1858
Posted: Sat Jul 21, 2012 6:55 pm
by EdLee
Basics. Basic broken shapes.
Re: A beginner's journal of little interest
Posted: Sat Jul 21, 2012 7:19 pm
by Boidhre
Thank you for the detailed comments Ed.
Posted: Sat Jul 21, 2012 7:25 pm
by EdLee
Boidhre, broken shapes can take a long time to fix (they did for me

).
Are you getting any sense of what they are yet, or, still no feelings at all toward them?
Re:
Posted: Sat Jul 21, 2012 7:28 pm
by Boidhre
EdLee wrote:Boidhre, broken shapes can take a long time to fix (they did for me

).
Are you getting any sense of what they are yet, or, still no feelings at all toward them?
Sometimes I see them in potential moves, sometimes I see opportunities to make them in my opponent's moves (though I'm not sure if I should or not). Often I'm oblivious until after the fact.
I figure it'll come in time like most things seem to in go.
Re: Re:
Posted: Sat Jul 21, 2012 8:02 pm
by EdLee
Boidhre wrote:(a) Sometimes I see them in potential moves
Good.
Boidhre wrote:(b) Often I'm oblivious until after the fact.

Yes, bad.

Boidhre wrote:(c) sometimes I see opportunities to make them in my opponent's moves
Good...
Boidhre wrote:(d) though I'm not sure if I should or not.
...yes, this is the next step, and more difficult.
Boidhre wrote:I figure it'll come in time like most things seem to in go.
Hmmm... the most important thing now is (b), IMHO.
Recently, there's a lively discussion here:
viewtopic.php?f=10&t=6327You're still in the very early phase of recognizing/seeing the basic broken shapes.
You must work hard to see them ahead of time; just one move ahead of time, not even two --
Maybe 95%+ of the notes about your broken shapes are only 1-move ahead?
Have you gone through all your games, in this thread alone, multiple times each, just seeing the broken shapes?

$$
$$ . . . . . . . . . . . . .
$$ . . X . . . . . . X . . .
$$ . O O O O . . . O O O . .
$$ . . . X . . . . . X . . .
$$ . . . . . . . . . . . . .
- Click Here To Show Diagram Code
[go]$$
$$ . . . . . . . . . . . . .
$$ . . X . . . . . . X . . .
$$ . O O O O . . . O O O . .
$$ . . . X . . . . . X . . .
$$ . . . . . . . . . . . . .[/go]
Re: Re:
Posted: Sat Jul 21, 2012 8:08 pm
by Boidhre
EdLee wrote:Boidhre wrote:(a) Sometimes I see them in potential moves
Good.
Boidhre wrote:(b) Often I'm oblivious until after the fact.

Yes, bad.

Boidhre wrote:(c) sometimes I see opportunities to make them in my opponent's moves
Good...
Boidhre wrote:(d) though I'm not sure if I should or not.
...yes, this is the next step, and more difficult.
Boidhre wrote:I figure it'll come in time like most things seem to in go.
Hmmm... the most important thing now is (b), IMHO.
Recently, there's a lively discussion here:
http://www.lifein19x19.com/forum/viewto ... =10&t=6327You're still in the very early phase of recognizing/seeing the basic broken shapes.
You must work hard to see them ahead of time; just one move ahead of time, not even two --
Maybe 95%+ of the notes about your broken shapes are only 1-move ahead?
Have you gone through all your games, in this thread alone, multiple times each, just seeing the broken shapes?

$$
$$ . . . . . . . . . . . . .
$$ . . X . . . . . . X . . .
$$ . O O O O . . . O O O . .
$$ . . . X . . . . . X . . .
$$ . . . . . . . . . . . . .
- Click Here To Show Diagram Code
[go]$$
$$ . . . . . . . . . . . . .
$$ . . X . . . . . . X . . .
$$ . O O O O . . . O O O . .
$$ . . . X . . . . . X . . .
$$ . . . . . . . . . . . . .[/go]
I've tried to keep in mind what shapes are broken when playing. I recognise them in my reviews. I've yet to translate that into seeing them ahead in games. I know the biggest problem for me is the broken keima. I just don't see it far too often. I'm starting to see more of these in my opponent's moves which I assume is the prelude to being able to see them ahead in my own.
Re: A beginner's journal of little interest
Posted: Sat Jul 21, 2012 10:44 pm
by Boidhre
I do wonder at the moment, does my depression (current) affect my go? I mean do I play passively, do I play meekly? I do dwell on this a bit, not because my current rank is very important to me, my rank will sort itself out over time, but because I wonder if go is a reflection of one's current mentality. When high, I feel I play with confidence and perhaps above my rank, when low I feel I play under my rank and meekly. Is this perception correct? Do others see it in my go? (Idle question rather than serious

)
Re: A beginner's journal of little interest
Posted: Sat Jul 21, 2012 11:04 pm
by lemmata
Perhaps it is a matter of impatience. When I am on a losing streak, I often feel the urge to push an advantage too hard and decide the game quickly. This often leads to bad overplay that turns a winning position into a losing one.
There is also fear of uncertainty. When I am feeling weak, I might feel like playing a low move where a high move is appropriate because I like the certainty of the low move. It reduces the number of possible futures for that position. Of course, what I am neglecting is that it eliminates mostly good futures for me if the opponent plays correctly. It's paradoxical. The fear of uncertainty makes me choose the certain loss of profit. This also appears in my habit of playing unnecessary forcing moves so that I can reduce the number of possible futures.
These are all flaws that we exhibit in real life away from the go board.
The psychology of go really spans the entire spectrum of human experience.
Posted: Sat Jul 21, 2012 11:42 pm
by EdLee
Boidhre wrote:I wonder if go is a reflection of one's current mentality.
Very much so.
Re: A beginner's journal of little interest
Posted: Sun Jul 22, 2012 5:31 am
by daal
Boidhre wrote:I do wonder at the moment, does my depression (current) affect my go? I mean do I play passively, do I play meekly? I do dwell on this a bit, not because my current rank is very important to me, my rank will sort itself out over time, but because I wonder if go is a reflection of one's current mentality. When high, I feel I play with confidence and perhaps above my rank, when low I feel I play under my rank and meekly. Is this perception correct? Do others see it in my go? (Idle question rather than serious

)
I think this is something that many of us struggle with, depressed or not. I think it's a good idea, whether you are up or down to try to stay aware of any tendency or desire to play meek and cowardly moves and nip it in the bud. My experience is that even when I lose games where I've played what seemed to be the courageous move, the games have been more interesting and more fun than had I chosen the spineless route. Going down the submissive and compliant path leads to games where losing is harder to swallow, so, even if you're down, don't miss the opportunity for a thrilling and invigorating fight.
Re: A beginner's journal of little interest
Posted: Sun Jul 22, 2012 9:54 am
by Bill Spight
Your opponent played very nicely.
(;ST[2]AP[GOWrite:2.2.21]GM[1]CA[UTF-8]FF[4]SZ[19]FG[259:]TM[1500.0]RU[Japanese]BR[10k]RE[W+46.50]PB[Boidhre]PC[The KGS Go Server at http\://www.gokgs.com/]WR[7k]C[ ]KM[0.5]HA[3]PW[Seanachain]DT[2012-07-21]AB[dp][pp][pd]OT[5x30 byo-yomi]PM[0]GN[GoGoDW2011Seanachain-Boidhre]
;WL[1451.0]W[cd]
(
;BL[1491.0]C[*** See variations.]B[ed]
;WL[1445.3]W[gd]
;BL[1471.6]B[ef]
;WL[1435.1]W[cf]
(
;BL[1449.3]C[*** Not so good. See variation.]B[he]
;WL[1430.4]W[hd]
;BL[1433.8]B[ie]
;WL[1359.6]W[jc]
;BL[1352.6]C[*** Good.]B[dh]
;WL[1309.0]W[ch]
;BL[1303.8]C[Seanachain \[7k\]\: well I have to go to a shop about 20 mins away
Seanachain \[7k\]\: I'll go after, tis grand
Boidhre \[10k\]\: ok
]B[di]
;WL[1254.8]W[nq]
;BL[1263.3]B[jq]
;WL[1201.6]W[qn]
;BL[1211.9]B[np]
;WL[1195.2]W[mp]
;BL[1194.4]B[no]
;WL[1192.4]W[oq]
;BL[1190.4]B[pq]
;WL[1185.4]W[kq]
;BL[1164.9]B[kp]
;WL[1165.3]W[op]
(
;BL[1068.5]C[*** Not good. See variation.]B[qo]
;WL[1158.3]W[pn]
;BL[971.5]B[oo]
;WL[1125.5]W[po]
;BL[958.0]B[ro]
;WL[1075.8]W[lp]
(
;BL[919.9]C[*** See variation.]B[jp]
;WL[1072.8]W[mn]C[*** Oops!]
(
;BL[848.5]C[*** See variation.]B[qj]
;WL[1053.0]W[qg]
(
;BL[827.3]C[*** See variation.]B[nc]
;WL[1045.1]W[lc]
(
;BL[813.1]C[*** See variation.]B[oj]
;WL[1034.8]W[qc]
;BL[797.4]B[qd]
;WL[972.2]W[pb]
(
;BL[753.7]C[*** See variaton.]B[nb]
;WL[952.4]W[rd]
;BL[750.4]B[re]
;WL[949.8]W[rb]
(
;BL[744.4]C[*** See variation.]B[qe]
;WL[944.2]W[sc]
(
;BL[715.3]C[*** Big. But see variation.]B[ci]
;WL[940.7]W[bh]
;BL[708.3]C[*** Not so big. White is secure here.]B[bi]
;WL[938.7]W[dc]
;BL[706.2]C[*** Not so big now, since both White groups are reasonably strong. There is a chance of attacking the White group on the top side, however.]B[ec]
;WL[933.1]W[cn]
;BL[673.1]C[*** Good locally.]B[co]
;WL[927.3]W[dn]
;BL[670.5]B[fp]
;WL[921.2]W[og]C[*** Difficult position.]
(
;BL[598.4]C[*** Strengthens White. See variation. End of comments.]B[rh]
;WL[917.5]W[rg]
;BL[592.7]B[pg]
;WL[891.5]W[ph]
;BL[590.6]B[pf]
;WL[883.1]W[qh]
;BL[588.9]B[oh]
;WL[877.2]W[oi]
;BL[586.9]B[nh]
;WL[846.8]W[pi]
;BL[557.3]B[ni]
;WL[843.7]W[pj]
;BL[549.2]B[pk]
;WL[841.8]W[ok]
;BL[542.9]B[nj]
;WL[823.4]W[ol]
;BL[473.2]B[nf]
;WL[815.9]W[qk]
;BL[440.5]B[rk]
;WL[797.6]W[ql]
;BL[408.6]B[sm]
;WL[790.2]W[rq]
;BL[362.0]B[pr]
;WL[778.2]W[rr]
;BL[313.8]C[ ]B[rs]
;WL[745.3]W[qp]
;BL[286.2]B[rn]
;WL[733.9]W[or]
;BL[253.2]B[os]
;WL[728.0]W[mq]
;BL[238.0]B[qr]
;WL[718.7]W[ns]
;BL[165.2]B[rp]
;WL[678.0]W[qs]
;BL[118.2]B[qq]
;WL[667.8]W[ss]
;BL[69.3]B[sq]
;WL[636.5]W[sp]
;BL[47.5]B[so]
;WL[628.1]W[ps]
;BL[44.1]B[qp]
;WL[610.5]W[rm]
;BL[5.6]B[fm]
;WL[585.4]W[cl]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[ek]
;WL[580.8]W[eo]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[ep]
;WL[578.9]W[fo]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[go]
;WL[562.4]W[gn]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[fn]
;WL[550.8]W[gp]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[ho]
;WL[548.8]W[gq]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[fq]
;WL[546.5]W[kr]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[jr]
;WL[536.3]W[cq]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[bo]
;WL[534.3]W[dr]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[ar]
;WL[531.4]W[fr]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[gr]
;WL[529.2]W[hr]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[er]
;WL[526.9]W[gs]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[es]
;WL[522.5]W[ds]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[eq]
;WL[515.5]W[cp]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[do]
;WL[513.2]W[br]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[aq]
;WL[507.6]W[en]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[bn]
;WL[505.5]W[bm]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[hm]
;WL[442.1]W[in]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[hn]
;WL[436.5]W[ip]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[jn]
;WL[420.0]W[ir]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[is]
;WL[417.3]W[em]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[gm]
;WL[405.4]W[iq]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[io]
;WL[387.2]W[fs]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[hp]
;WL[381.9]W[bp]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[ap]
;WL[377.4]W[an]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[hq]
;WL[363.5]W[el]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[fl]
;WL[360.4]W[dk]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[dm]
;WL[357.3]W[bk]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[ej]
;WL[350.0]W[kf]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[kh]
;WL[330.6]W[ko]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[jo]
;WL[327.4]W[mg]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[ng]
;WL[317.1]W[ge]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[gf]
;WL[308.9]W[dg]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[eg]
;WL[301.1]W[ig]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[hf]
;WL[292.0]W[jd]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[jf]
;WL[289.8]W[je]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[if]
;WL[283.3]W[kg]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[jg]
;WL[274.9]W[ll]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[kk]
;WL[261.8]W[kl]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[jl]
;WL[259.8]W[jk]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[il]
;WL[248.3]W[mf]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[la]
;WL[228.0]W[lj]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[mh]
;WL[225.3]W[jh]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[ji]
;WL[223.6]W[lh]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[ki]
;WL[222.3]W[li]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[me]
;WL[219.3]W[le]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[md]
;WL[214.4]W[kb]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[ka]
;WL[212.6]W[ja]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[ma]
;WL[208.7]W[gb]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[eb]
;WL[198.6]W[db]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[kj]
;WL[196.3]W[lk]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[ih]
;WL[193.7]W[ks]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[js]
;WL[187.9]W[am]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[gr]
;WL[185.2]W[ao]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[dq]
;WL[169.7]W[bq]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[cs]
;WL[167.2]W[as]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[cr]
;WL[150.6]W[fe]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[ee]
;WL[147.1]W[ff]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[fg]
;WL[130.2]W[kn]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[da]
;WL[128.1]W[ca]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[ea]
;WL[126.2]W[bb]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[ah]
;WL[123.6]W[ag]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[ai]
;WL[121.0]W[bf]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[se]
;WL[100.3]W[mb]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[na]
;WL[90.4]W[oc]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[od]
;WL[80.6]W[mc]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[nd]
;WL[72.1]W[sd]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[pc]
;WL[69.6]W[ob]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[oa]
;WL[63.8]W[pa]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[sg]
;WL[59.1]W[ri]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[sh]
;WL[56.7]W[si]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[sf]
;WL[33.5]W[aj]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[bj]
;WL[29.9]W[ak]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[dj]
;WL[23.5]W[fa]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[fb]
;WL[21.3]W[ga]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[gc]
;WL[9.7]W[hc]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[fc]
;WL[8.0]W[ib]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[ld]
;WL[1.5]W[kd]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[lb]
;OW[5]WL[30.0]W[kc]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[km]
;OW[5]WL[30.0]W[lm]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[jm]
;OW[5]WL[30.0]W[nk]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[mj]
;OW[5]WL[30.0]W[mk]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[cj]
;OW[5]WL[30.0]W[ck]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]C[ ]B[hs]
;OW[4]WL[30.0]W[bs]
(
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[de]
;OW[3]WL[30.0]W[ce]
;OB[5]BL[30.0]B[df]
;OW[3]WL[30.0]W[cg]
;OB[4]BL[30.0]B[dd]
;OW[2]WL[30.0]W[id]
;OB[3]BL[30.0]B[tt]
;OW[2]WL[30.0]W[pl]
;OB[3]BL[30.0]B[tt]
;OW[2]WL[30.0]TB[dr:ds][eh:hh][ei:ii][fj:jk][fr][fs:gs][gg:ig][gl:hl][gn][gp:gq][hr:ir][im:in][ip:iq][jh][ne:pe][of:og]W[tt]TW[aa:ba][ab][ac:cc][ad:be][af][al:bl][ap:ar][bg][cb][cm:dm][dl][ha:ia][hb][ic][jb][ke][lf:lg][ln][lo:oo][lq][lr:nr][ls:ms][ml:nl][mm:qm][nn:on][np][os][pk][pp:sp][pq:qr][qa:sa][qb][qi][qj:sj][qo:so][rc][rk:sl][rn:sn][rs][sb][sm][sq:sr]
)
(
;OB[5]BL[30.0]C[Boidhre \[10k\]\: or 1
Seanachain \[7k\]\: D2 isnt needed
Boidhre \[10k\]\: good point
Seanachain \[7k\]\: you can undo if you want
]B[dr]
)
)
(
;C[*** Topping the tree. This kind of play is often called for in such fights. The future is unclear, but you at least get in White's way. Each side has two weak groups in this fight, but the White group in the top right is the weakest. Besides, this play is likely to help build a center moyo or aid in the attack in the lower left.]B[mg]
)
)
(
;C[*** Letting White play here is not so good, as we saw later. There are other moves to prepare against it, but this is simple and strong.]B[og]
)
)
(
;B[sd]
;W[rc]
;C[*** See threat after pass.]B[qf]
;W[tt]
;B[qa]
;W[pa]
;B[sc]
;W[sb]
;B[ra]
;W[se]
;B[sd]
;W[sf]
;B[rg]
)
)
(
;B[rc]
(
;W[rb]
;B[pc]
;W[qb]
;B[rd]
;W[ob]
;B[mc]
;W[sb]
;B[ld]
)
(
;W[nb]
;B[oc]
;W[ob]
;B[mc]
;W[mb]
;B[ld]
;W[kd]
;B[le]
)
)
)
(
;C[*** Pincer. Attack while making territory.]B[qe]
)
)
(
;C[*** Pincer. The Black stone has room for a base, the White stone does not.]B[qe]
)
)
(
;C[*** Bigger than it looks. See threat after pass.]B[rn]
(
;W[tt]
;B[qm]
(
;W[pm]
;B[pl]
)
(
;W[on]
)
)
(
;W[ql]
;C[*** See threat after pass.]B[pr]
;W[tt]
;B[mq]
;W[mr]
;B[nr]
;W[lq]
;B[or]
;W[mq]C[*** For later.]
)
)
)
(
;B[nm]
)
)
(
;B[po]
;W[oo]
;B[pn]
;W[on]
;B[pm]
)
)
(
;B[cc]
;W[bc]
;B[dc]
;W[bb]
;C[*** Attack while building a moyo.]B[jd]
)
)
(
;B[fd]
)
(
;C[*** Perhaps the most practical play. A pincer is not severe, and there are few variations.]B[fc]
)
)
Re: A beginner's journal of little interest
Posted: Sun Jul 22, 2012 10:02 am
by Boidhre
Thanks Bill, plenty to chew over there.
