oca's D14 cutting exercise started from move 131, instead of the suggested move 129. won't that make some difference with/out the H12/G12 exchange?
Re: OCA's log
Posted: Wed Apr 08, 2015 6:45 am
by Knotwilg
(BTW, I concur with Ed on most of his comments, so you can deal with my comments as efficiently as you want)
Game 1 Highlights:
- 39-40: both seem in no hurry to settle the hot upper left - 68: opportunity to destroy Black - 76: an exercise in global or local thinking (for me too) - 102: how to win a won game, by Oca!
(;GM[1]FF[4]CA[UTF-8]AP[CGoban:3]ST[2] RU[Japanese]SZ[19]KM[6.50]TM[60] GN[oca-menttogo(B) IGS]PW[oca]PB[menttogo]WR[12k]BR[13k]DT[2015-04-01]CP[ Copyright (c) PANDANET Inc. 2015 Permission to reproduce this game is given, provided proper credit is given. No warrantee, implied or explicit, is understood. Use of this game is an understanding and agreement of this notice. ]EV[Internet Go Server game: oca vs menttogo]PC[IGS: igs.joyjoy.net 6969]US[Brought to you by IGS PANDANET]RE[W+Resign]LT[]NB[16]NW[17]RR[Normal] ;B[dp]BL[58]C[ menttogo 13k+: 45 hello oca 12k : Hello menttogo oca 12k : Have a Nice game oca 12k : Hi! ] ;W[dd]WL[23]C[ menttogo 13k+: 45 to you also ] ;B[pp]BL[46] ;W[qd]WL[3] ;B[pj]BL[45] ;W[oc]WL[584] ;B[fc]BL[43] ;W[hc]WL[578] ;B[fe]BL[42] ;W[df]WL[563] ;B[db]BL[40] ;W[cc]WL[558] ;B[cb]BL[39] (;W[kc]WL[518] ;B[bc]BL[35] ;W[bd]WL[515] ;B[dc]BL[34] ;W[cd]WL[496] ;B[bb]BL[32]TR[hc]SQ[cc][bd][cd][dd][df]C[Now Black is safe and White is cramped
The squared stones are heavier than the triangled one, which got the support] ;W[cj]WL[460] (;B[dh]BL[30] (;W[eg]WL[440] ;B[eh]BL[26] ;W[fg]WL[424] ;B[ej]BL[19] ;W[cn]WL[394] ;B[cl]BL[16] ;W[cq]WL[375] ;B[cp]BL[15] ;W[dq]WL[367] ;B[eq]BL[13] ;W[bq]WL[360] ;B[bp]BL[12] ;W[ep]WL[356] ;B[eo]BL[6] ;W[fp]WL[349] ;B[dn]BL[5] ;W[fq]WL[298]C[Locally this is a good result indeed.
As Ed points out, there's unfinished business at the top left. You have a floating group that can still be surrounded.] ;B[nq]BL[600]C[But Black seems to be in no hurry attacking it] ;W[qp]WL[262]C[Both of you worry more about the development at the lower right than the stability of existing stones at the top left.
This is a common mistake that IMO stems from mistakingly thinking about Go as a game where you have to surround empty points.] ;B[qq]BL[598] ;W[qo]WL[234] ;B[rq]BL[595] ;W[ql]WL[226] ;B[qj]BL[592] ;W[po]WL[221] ;B[op]BL[591] ;W[nn]WL[207] ;B[qg]BL[589] (;W[dk]WL[190]LB[eg:A][cj:B]C[While A is weak, you decide to invest in B.
This is heavy play. See variation ] ;B[ck]BL[586]C[Fortunately Black comes to rescue with this terrible move] ;W[dj]WL[177] ;B[dl]BL[585]C[And another one] ;W[ek]WL[174] ;B[fj]BL[584] ;W[gl]WL[563]LB[fh:A]C[You can first destroy his shape at A ] ;B[fk]BL[581] ;W[bj]WL[549] ;B[bh]BL[578] ;W[el]WL[510] ;B[fl]BL[576] ;W[em]WL[507] ;B[fm]BL[575] ;W[dm]WL[500] ;B[cm]BL[574] ;W[bn]WL[492] ;B[bm]BL[568] (;W[am]WL[483]C[There is a faster way to destroy Black] ;B[al]BL[567] ;W[an]WL[468] ;B[en]BL[563]LB[bi:3][ci:2][di:1][aj:4][ao:C][bo:B][co:A]TR[bk][bl]C[White has 4 libs and 3 libs respectively
Black has 2] ;W[bk]WL[454]C[Pass move
Count liberties] ;B[bf]BL[556] ;W[hg]WL[428]C[Good defensive move. Simple moves like these win.] ;B[kq]BL[550] (;W[iq]WL[412]LB[iq:2][kq:1]TR[bf][bh][dh][eh][ej][fj][fk][fl][fm][dn][en][eo][bp][cp][dp]SQ[cc][bd][cd][dd][df][eg][fg][hg]C[Black ignores his weakness. White indirectly takes it into account, but not on purpose I think. See var.] ;B[gm]BL[547] ;W[gd]WL[385] ;B[fd]BL[546] ;W[ge]WL[360] ;B[md]BL[542] (;W[mb]WL[341]C[Attack!] ;B[oe]BL[536] ;W[nd]WL[324] ;B[ne]BL[535] ;W[me]WL[320] ;B[ld]BL[532] ;W[mf]WL[310] ;B[ke]BL[598] ;W[kg]WL[295] ;B[od]BL[584] ;W[nc]WL[289] ;B[pc]BL[583] ;W[qc]WL[249] ;B[pd]BL[573] ;W[pb]WL[246] ;B[qb]BL[572] ;W[rb]WL[231] ;B[qe]BL[567] ;W[qa]WL[225] ;B[hj]BL[553] ;W[ol]WL[156]C[Very calm move Very good.
End of comments] ;B[oj]BL[540] ;W[jo]WL[123] ;B[jp]BL[536] ;W[ip]WL[596] ;B[io]BL[535] ;W[kp]WL[589] ;B[jq]BL[534] ;W[ir]WL[577] ;B[in]BL[532] (;W[lo]WL[567] ;B[lp]BL[531] ;W[ko]WL[553] ;B[mp]BL[530] ;W[mo]WL[549] ;B[oo]BL[528] ;W[on]WL[544] ;B[aq]BL[503] ;W[br]WL[516] ;B[jl]BL[496] ;W[mg]WL[487] ;B[og]BL[493] ;W[jg]WL[465] ;B[nh]BL[483] ;W[mh]WL[460] ;B[mi]BL[482] ;W[ff]WL[454] ;B[gc]BL[480] ;W[hb]WL[450] ;B[gb]BL[479] ;W[id]WL[445] ;B[li]BL[474] ;W[mk]WL[417] ;B[kj]BL[466] ;W[nj]WL[411] ;B[ni]BL[465] ;W[ho]WL[389] ;B[hn]BL[598] ;W[go]WL[386] ;B[fn]BL[597] ;W[km]WL[375] ;B[nk]BL[593] ;W[nl]WL[368] ;B[mj]BL[591] ;W[lk]WL[365] ;B[kk]BL[588] ;W[kl]WL[361] ;B[jm]BL[586] ;W[re]WL[348] ;B[rf]BL[584] ;W[rd]WL[342] ;B[rg]BL[582] ;W[kr]WL[315] ;B[lr]BL[579] ;W[jr]WL[595] ;B[lq]BL[578] ;W[rp]WL[590] ;B[sp]BL[577] ;W[so]WL[586] ;B[sq]BL[576] ;W[cg]WL[577] ;B[ch]BL[574] ;W[rk]WL[560] ;B[rj]BL[571] ;W[fh]WL[506] ;B[fi]BL[566] ;W[gi]WL[484] ;B[hi]BL[551] ;W[gh]WL[478] ;B[gj]BL[550] ;W[ji]WL[474] ;B[ih]BL[546] ;W[ig]WL[471] ;B[jh]BL[545] ;W[kh]WL[465] ;B[ki]BL[543] ;W[ar]WL[429] ;B[ap]BL[535] ;W[ls]WL[416] ;B[ms]BL[533] ;W[ks]WL[413] ;B[nr]BL[532] ;W[ha]WL[400] ;B[qk]BL[528] ;W[rl]WL[396] ;B[pl]BL[527] ;W[pm]WL[392] ;B[pk]BL[599] ;W[sj]WL[384] ;B[si]BL[598] ;W[sk]WL[381] ;B[cf]BL[584] ;W[dg]WL[336] ;B[de]BL[562] ;W[ee]WL[330] ;B[ce]BL[561] ;W[ed]WL[327] ;B[ec]BL[559] ;W[bg]WL[318] ;B[af]BL[553] ;W[ag]WL[296] ;B[ad]BL[551] ;W[ae]WL[280] ;B[co]BL[536] ;W[bl]WL[581] ;B[ah]BL[531] ;W[be]WL[577] ;B[ac]BL[529] ;W[hh]WL[568] ;B[ii]BL[528] ;W[di]WL[564] ;B[ei]BL[527] ;W[ga]WL[498] ;B[fa]BL[525] ;W[ok]WL[475] ;B[rn]BL[522] ;W[ro]WL[422] ;B[qm]BL[509] ;W[rm]WL[414] ;B[sn]BL[479] ;W[qn]WL[408] ;B[nj]BL[474] ;W[mm]WL[380] ;B[lh]BL[462] ;W[lg]WL[377] ;B[nf]BL[460] ;OS[domini1000]) (;W[lq] ;B[ko] ;W[kr] ;B[lp] ;W[jr] ;B[jn] ;W[mq] ;B[mp] ;W[nr] ;B[or] ;W[mr])) (;W[pf] ;B[pg] ;W[of] ;B[mf] ;W[og])) (;W[fh] ;B[ei] (;W[fn]C[White can cut and grab the loot.] (;B[fo]C[If Black resists] ;W[gn] ;B[go] ;W[hn]C[White's cut is devastating]) (;B[gn]C[Black could sacrifice] ;W[fo] ;B[hj] ;W[jg]C[But it's hard to see how Black will win])) (;W[hi]C[White could be patient too.] ;B[gn] ;W[og]C[From a global standpoint this may be best.]))) (;W[en] ;B[do] (;W[bk]C[One option] ;B[fo] ;W[fn] ;B[go] ;W[gn]) (;W[fo] (;B[an] ;W[bk] ;B[bo] ;W[ap] ;B[fn] ;W[bl] ;B[co] ;W[al]C[White wins the capturing race and Black has lots of work to do.]) (;B[bk] ;W[ao] ;B[ap] ;W[aq] ;B[am] ;W[bo] ;B[fn] ;W[ak] ;B[al] ;W[aj] ;B[di] ;W[co] ;B[bi] ;W[an])))) (;W[gd] (;B[fd] ;W[hg]) (;B[ee] ;W[bf]LB[ge:B][bh:A]))) (;W[ch]C[Natural connection])) (;B[cl]LB[ch:A]C[Black can develop freely here because White has left a natural invasion point at A])) (;W[bb]C[As Ed points out, this move is vital for both eye spaces]))
Game 2 Highlights:
- 19: Black can take the loot AND avoid White influence. On this occasion the costly mistake could even be game deciding. By 24 White is by no means behind - 39: Nice discovery!!! But please do continue ... - 58-76: too easy for White. - 93: game deciding mistake - 111: White was slack this time but the comeback is not enough
(;GM[1]FF[4]CA[UTF-8]AP[CGoban:3]ST[2] RU[Japanese]SZ[19]KM[0.50]TM[1800] GN[bee2014119-oca(B) IGS]PW[bee2014119]PB[oca]WR[12k]BR[12k]DT[2015-04-01]CP[ Copyright (c) PANDANET Inc. 2015 Permission to reproduce this game is given, provided proper credit is given. No warrantee, implied or explicit, is understood. Use of this game is an understanding and agreement of this notice. ]EV[Internet Go Server game: bee2014119 vs oca]PC[IGS: igs.joyjoy.net 6969]US[Brought to you by IGS PANDANET]C[ oca 12k : Hi! ]RE[W+Resign]LT[]NB[17]NW[17]RR[Normal] ;B[pd]BL[1793] ;W[dq]WL[1796]C[ oca 12k : Hello bee bee2014119 12k+: 24 hi oca 12k : Have a good game ! ] ;B[cd]BL[1758] ;W[pp]WL[1778] ;B[ic]BL[1731] ;W[cg]WL[1751] ;B[ed]BL[1698] ;W[cl]WL[1713] ;B[nq]BL[1681] ;W[lq]WL[1707] ;B[qq]BL[1676] ;W[pq]WL[1679] ;B[qp]BL[1671] ;W[qo]WL[1676] ;B[qr]BL[1664] ;W[pr]WL[1673] ;B[po]BL[1661] ;W[np]WL[1668]C[Here White makes a second mistake. See var] (;B[qn]BL[1638] ;W[oo]WL[1663] ;B[pn]BL[1632] ;W[nm]WL[1565] (;B[pj]BL[1610]LB[nd:B][qg:A][co:C]C[The bottom right is small. So you have to invest in the top right
White's prospects are bigger however and you have territory in the bag, so you could invade at C] ;W[do]WL[1422]C[Big by White] ;B[nc]BL[1546] (;W[qg]WL[1339]C[My feeling is that WHite should build, not destroy] ;B[qi]BL[1509] ;W[rd]WL[1312] ;B[qc]BL[1479] ;W[rc]WL[1307] ;B[og]BL[1403] ;W[qb]WL[1291] ;B[pb]BL[1399] ;W[qd]WL[1291] ;B[pc]BL[1392] ;W[rb]WL[1285] ;B[eg]BL[1325] ;W[di]WL[1261] ;B[mp]BL[1289]C[I didn't think of this weakness at all!] ;W[mq]WL[1173] ;B[no]BL[1272] ;W[op]WL[1170] (;B[jp]BL[1166]C[Please continue!] ;W[ko]WL[1114] ;B[im]BL[1088] ;W[jo]WL[1080] ;B[io]BL[1084] ;W[in]WL[1074] ;B[hn]BL[1081] ;W[jn]WL[1070] (;B[ho]BL[1068] ;W[gq]WL[949] ;B[hm]BL[1014] ;W[jk]WL[926] ;B[hk]BL[959] ;W[hi]WL[872]C[It seems that this good capping move has turned the flow of the game] ;B[ij]BL[800] ;W[hd]WL[707] (;B[kd]BL[778]C[This is not an answer to the shoulder hit!] ;W[hc]WL[697] ;B[ji]BL[743] ;W[ib]WL[672] ;B[jc]BL[732] ;W[ef]WL[653] ;B[fe]BL[708] ;W[ff]WL[647] ;B[ge]BL[704] ;W[eb]WL[642] ;B[fc]BL[676] ;W[fb]WL[641] ;B[hf]BL[657] ;W[dc]WL[636] ;B[dd]BL[654] ;W[ie]WL[625] ;B[if]BL[614] ;W[bb]WL[608]C[This has been way too easy for White] ;B[jf]BL[501] ;W[jb]WL[592] ;B[kb]BL[496] ;W[ol]WL[571] ;B[ql]BL[486] ;W[rh]WL[561] ;B[ri]BL[468] ;W[nj]WL[560] ;B[lj]BL[442] ;W[mi]WL[555] ;B[kl]BL[431] ;W[jm]WL[545] ;B[jl]BL[428] ;W[mg]WL[531] ;B[nh]BL[382] ;W[hq]WL[526] ;B[jr]BL[366] ;W[ip]WL[524]C[Huge] ;B[kp]BL[339] ;W[lp]WL[516] ;B[lo]BL[333] ;W[mo]WL[506] ;B[ln]BL[327] ;W[jq]WL[505] ;B[cp]BL[308] ;W[co]WL[483] ;B[dp]BL[285] (;W[eq]WL[473] ;B[ep]BL[277] ;W[fp]WL[407] ;B[eo]BL[272] ;W[fo]WL[406] ;B[en]BL[269] ;W[bo]WL[378] ;B[fn]BL[262]C[A major comeback but not enough to reverse the game result] ;W[mh]WL[361] ;B[dk]BL[235] ;W[ck]WL[353] ;B[dj]BL[211] ;W[cj]WL[351] ;B[ei]BL[208] ;W[dh]WL[284] ;B[eh]BL[197] ;W[dg]WL[281] ;B[ok]BL[110] ;W[nk]WL[277] ;B[nn]BL[71] ;W[on]WL[207] ;B[mn]BL[42] ;W[gg]WL[202] ;B[gf]BL[2] ;W[fg]WL[199] ;B[hh]BL[570] ;W[gh]WL[190] ;B[fk]BL[546] ;W[fi]WL[185] ;B[ej]BL[508] ;W[si]WL[152] ;B[sj]BL[501] ;W[sh]WL[152] ;B[rk]BL[487] ;W[me]WL[149] ;B[md]BL[463] ;W[dm]WL[87] ;B[ni]BL[421] ;W[mj]WL[82] ;B[em]BL[401] ;W[oj]WL[588] ;B[nf]BL[351] ;W[mf]WL[585] ;B[ne]BL[345] ;W[lk]WL[567] ;B[kk]BL[341] ;W[kj]WL[556] ;B[jj]BL[335] ;W[ki]WL[547] ;B[kh]BL[327] ;W[li]WL[546] ;B[km]BL[312] ;W[kq]WL[543] ;B[cf]BL[297] ;W[df]WL[541] ;B[bf]BL[281] ;W[bg]WL[540] ;B[cc]BL[265] ;W[cb]WL[539] ;B[ec]BL[258] ;W[db]WL[538] ;B[cq]BL[238] ;W[cr]WL[529] ;B[dn]BL[212] ;W[cn]WL[526] ;B[dl]BL[208] ;W[cm]WL[524] ;B[qh]BL[194] ;W[rf]WL[519] ;B[qe]BL[181] ;W[re]WL[501] ;B[pf]BL[154] ;W[br]WL[497] ;B[bq]BL[146] ;W[oi]WL[472] ;B[or]BL[475] ;W[qs]WL[468] ;B[mp]BL[461] ;W[pm]WL[460] ;B[qm]BL[446] ;W[rr]WL[456] ;B[rp]BL[406] ;W[rq]WL[441] ;B[sp]BL[363] ;W[sq]WL[425] ;B[ro]BL[360] ;W[kg]WL[397] ;B[jg]BL[356] ;W[lc]WL[396] ;B[ld]BL[347] ;W[hb]WL[575] ;B[he]BL[299] ;W[ka]WL[560] ;B[lb]BL[294] ;W[la]WL[556] ;B[ma]BL[286] ;W[ja]WL[555] ;B[mb]BL[283] ;W[jd]WL[553] ;B[lg]BL[278] ;W[ml]WL[441] ;B[pl]BL[211] ;W[om]WL[357] ;B[pk]BL[194] ;W[gj]WL[352] ;B[gk]BL[190] ;W[ih]WL[339] ;B[hg]BL[186] ;W[ii]WL[338] ;B[gc]BL[154] ;W[gb]WL[334] ;B[ag]BL[146] ;W[ah]WL[333] ;B[af]BL[140] ;W[bi]WL[332] ;B[mm]BL[112] ;W[bd]WL[292] ;B[rs]BL[105] ;W[ss]WL[289] ;B[os]BL[90] ;W[ps]WL[285] ;B[mr]BL[87] ;W[lr]WL[284] ;B[fr]BL[30] ;W[fq]WL[277] ;B[ir]BL[571] ;W[qf]WL[264] ;B[pe]BL[547] ;W[id]WL[261] ;B[kc]BL[543] ;W[kf]WL[254] ;B[lf]BL[527] ;W[ke]WL[241] ;B[le]BL[522] ;W[je]WL[240] ;B[jh]BL[512] ;W[bc]WL[236] ;B[be]BL[507] ;W[de]WL[233] ;B[ce]BL[499] ;W[gd]WL[589] ;B[ee]BL[488] ;W[ar]WL[584] ;B[aq]BL[485] ;W[ao]WL[582] ;B[gr]BL[468] ;W[hp]WL[576] ;B[er]BL[455] ;W[dr]WL[574] ;B[hr]BL[430] ;W[ks]WL[553] ;B[js]BL[407] ;W[es]WL[549] ;B[go]BL[379] ;W[hj]WL[530] ;B[fj]BL[371] ;W[lh]WL[516] ;B[fh]BL[321] ;W[gi]WL[514] ;B[ll]BL[300] ;W[kn]WL[506] ;B[lm]BL[290] ;W[mo]WL[503] ;B[ik]BL[277] ;W[ad]WL[499] ;B[qa]BL[270] ;W[ra]WL[482] ;B[pa]BL[259] ;W[mp]WL[457] ;B[sf]BL[229] ;W[se]WL[453]C[ oca 12k : Thx for the game I Will resign now ] ;OS[Maleficus1]) (;W[ep] ;B[cq] ;W[dr] ;B[bo] ;W[bn] ;B[cr] ;W[bp] ;B[bq] ;W[ao] ;B[eo] ;W[fp])) (;B[hc])) (;B[hm] ;W[ho] ;B[go] ;W[ip] ;B[ij])) (;B[on] ;W[nn] ;B[mo] (;W[nr] ;B[ln]) (;W[ln] ;B[or] ;W[lo] ;B[ps] ;W[lp] ;B[oq] ;W[kl]))) (;W[ie] ;B[gd] ;W[nj] ;B[ph])) (;B[co] ;W[cp] ;B[eo] ;W[fp] ;B[fo] ;W[gp] ;B[el]C[Like this?])) (;B[oo] ;W[op] ;B[no] ;W[mp] ;B[qn]))
Re: OCA's log
Posted: Mon Apr 13, 2015 8:51 am
by oca
Thanks a lot for your comments Knotwilg !
Re: OCA's log
Posted: Mon Apr 13, 2015 8:58 am
by oca
For now, I spent most of the time I have for go on 9x9 games. so not that much new to post... still played a new game that went fine for me, even if I missed that attack on the "should be" L+2 group in the bottom/left corner
$$Bc $$ +---------------------------------------+ $$ | . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . | $$ | . . . . . X O . O . O O . O O . . . . | $$ | . . . X . . X O . O X X X X X O O O . | $$ | . . . , . . X O . O . . . . . X X O . | $$ | . . . . . . . . . . . X . . . . . X . | $$ | . X X . . . X X X X O O X . . . X . . | $$ | . O . . X X O O X O O . X . X X . . . | $$ | . . O . O O X O O . . . . . O X . . . | $$ | . O . . . . . O X O O . O . O O X . . | $$ | . X O O O O . O X X . O X O X X X . . | $$ | . X O . X . O X . X . O X . O X . . . | $$ | . . . O X . X X . O . O X . O X O . . | $$ | a X X X . . . . . . O X X . O X X X . | $$ | 1 O X . . . X X O O X . . O . O O O . | $$ | . O X . . . X O . O X . X X O . . . . | $$ | 2 b O X . . X O . O X . . . X , O . . | $$ | . 3 O X . X O O . O X . . . X O . . . | $$ | . . O O X X O . . O X . . X O . O . . | $$ | . . O X . . . . . . . . . X O . . . . | $$ +---------------------------------------+
[go]$$Bc $$ +---------------------------------------+ $$ | . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . | $$ | . . . . . X O . O . O O . O O . . . . | $$ | . . . X . . X O . O X X X X X O O O . | $$ | . . . , . . X O . O . . . . . X X O . | $$ | . . . . . . . . . . . X . . . . . X . | $$ | . X X . . . X X X X O O X . . . X . . | $$ | . O . . X X O O X O O . X . X X . . . | $$ | . . O . O O X O O . . . . . O X . . . | $$ | . O . . . . . O X O O . O . O O X . . | $$ | . X O O O O . O X X . O X O X X X . . | $$ | . X O . X . O X . X . O X . O X . . . | $$ | . . . O X . X X . O . O X . O X O . . | $$ | a X X X . . . . . . O X X . O X X X . | $$ | 1 O X . . . X X O O X . . O . O O O . | $$ | . O X . . . X O . O X . X X O . . . . | $$ | 2 b O X . . X O . O X . . . X , O . . | $$ | . 3 O X . X O O . O X . . . X O . . . | $$ | . . O O X X O . . O X . . X O . O . . | $$ | . . O X . . . . . . . . . X O . . . . | $$ +---------------------------------------+[/go]
Here is wrong I think (should be at 'b'), but should be at 'a' instead of the the position in the diagram.
41: killing an invasion (difficult) 43: reducing an invasion to the smallest size (easy) 66-82: read about small gaps at http://senseis.xmp.net/?SmallGap 87: reward your cutting strategy with a final surround & kill 163: how about that corner (since you asked for it)
All in all an easy and well deserved win by applying a natural strategy based on thickness and cut/surround
(;GM[1]FF[4]CA[UTF-8]AP[CGoban:3]ST[2] RU[Japanese]SZ[19]KM[-5.50]TM[60] GN[yasuinooka-oca(B) IGS]PW[yasuinooka]PB[oca]WR[11k]BR[12k]DT[2015-04-13]CP[ Copyright (c) PANDANET Inc. 2015 Permission to reproduce this game is given, provided proper credit is given. No warrantee, implied or explicit, is understood. Use of this game is an understanding and agreement of this notice. ]EV[Internet Go Server game: yasuinooka vs oca]PC[IGS: igs.joyjoy.net 6969]US[Brought to you by IGS PANDANET]C[ yasuinooka 11k : Hi! oca 12k : Hi! ]RE[B+15.50]LT[]NB[17]NW[18]RR[Normal] ;B[pd]BL[53] ;W[qp]WL[60]C[ oca 12k : Hello have a good game. ] ;B[dc]BL[18] ;W[jd]WL[57] ;B[dp]BL[9] ;W[dj]WL[55] ;B[cf]BL[599] ;W[cq]WL[52] ;B[dq]BL[592] ;W[cp]WL[51] ;B[co]BL[589] ;W[bo]WL[50] ;B[cn]BL[587] ;W[bn]WL[49] ;B[cm]BL[583] ;W[dr]WL[49] ;B[er]BL[581] ;W[cr]WL[48] ;B[fq]BL[579]C[KW: very very good. You play normal moves which will always leave you with an advantage at this level.] ;W[hq]WL[46]C[KW: way too close to thickness] ;B[kq]BL[549]LB[op:A]C[KW: Good attacking move. White's stone is almost negligible however, so you could think of approaching his corner too.] ;W[ho]WL[42] ;B[ko]BL[531]LB[op:A]C[KW: now you can definitively think about approaching the corner.] ;W[jr]WL[39] ;B[kr]BL[529] ;W[jq]WL[37] ;B[oq]BL[524]C[KW: very good] ;W[pq]WL[34] ;B[op]BL[516] ;W[pn]WL[32] ;B[qj]BL[490]C[KW: your strategy is patient and interesting. Your groups are strong and you don't rush to attack White's weak groups. Instead you take big points, leaving his weaknesses to expose themselves later.] ;W[ql]WL[27] ;B[nc]BL[477] ;W[qc]WL[25] ;B[qd]BL[474] ;W[pc]WL[23] ;B[oc]BL[470] ;W[rd]WL[22] ;B[re]BL[467] ;W[rc]WL[22] (;B[qf]BL[463]C[KW: this is solid to the point of being slack. When White invades a small enclosure like that, you can think of killing him.
See variation.
However, playing solidly like this is not very wrong, let alone game losing.] ;W[ob]WL[22] (;B[gc]BL[437]LB[nb:A]C[KW: this however is much more important. You MUST further enclose White at A first, to punish him for the invasion. See var] ;W[nb]WL[16] ;B[mc]BL[433]C[Although the game is still good for you, White's corner invasions have been a little too easy] ;W[lb]WL[15]C[(this is not a strong follow-up by White)] ;B[el]BL[407] ;W[ch]WL[12] ;B[eg]BL[393] ;W[eh]WL[3] ;B[fg]BL[391] ;W[fh]WL[599] ;B[gh]BL[380] ;W[fj]WL[595] ;B[gl]BL[375]C[good splitting attack] ;W[gk]WL[593] ;B[hl]BL[598] ;W[jn]WL[587] ;B[kn]BL[585] ;W[jl]WL[581] ;B[hk]BL[581] ;W[hj]WL[578] ;B[ij]BL[534]C[you keep his groups separated; very good] ;W[hi]WL[574] ;B[ii]BL[521] ;W[hh]WL[571]SQ[bc][gh][ii]C[KW: the technical execution of the separation strategy can be better; you are pushing White through "small gaps"'] ;B[jk]BL[496] ;W[km]WL[567]SQ[jk][kn]C[same here] ;B[lm]BL[490] ;W[ll]WL[564]SQ[jk][lm]C[same here] ;B[mm]BL[487] ;W[gg]WL[561] ;B[gf]BL[484] ;W[hg]WL[558] ;B[hf]BL[477] ;W[jg]WL[553]SQ[hf][ii]C[same here] ;B[jf]BL[472] ;W[kg]WL[549]SQ[jf][ii]C[same here
A surrounding or cutting strategy will fail if tactically executed by pushing through small gaps] ;B[mg]BL[462] ;W[oi]WL[544]C[Overplay by White] ;B[ml]BL[456] ;W[lk]WL[540]SQ[jk][ml]C[small gaps] ;B[mj]BL[444] ;W[ok]WL[536] ;B[mk]BL[425] ;W[lj]WL[533]LB[li:A]C[KW: from here onwards, Black should hane at A.
In the end, White's negative strategy still lost him the game and you won by just responding thickly to his overplays, applying a cutting and connecting strategy.
Well done!
End of comments.] ;W[br]WL[578] ;B[ar]BL[506] ;W[aq]WL[573] ;B[am]BL[499] ;W[es]WL[566] ;B[fs]BL[492] ;W[gs]WL[563] ;B[ao]BL[482] ;W[bp]WL[560] ;B[fp]BL[466] ;W[dg]WL[547] ;B[df]BL[462] ;W[ke]WL[536] ;B[nh]BL[451] ;W[ni]WL[533] ;B[ga]BL[435] ;W[hb]WL[531] ;B[mb]BL[427] ;W[ma]WL[528] ;B[he]BL[415] ;W[ha]WL[521] ;B[fa]BL[411] ;W[af]WL[518] ;B[ae]BL[408] ;W[ag]WL[515] ;B[be]BL[405] ;W[cg]WL[512] ;B[ef]BL[402] ;W[aj]WL[508] ;B[cl]BL[384] ;W[ak]WL[503] ;B[bl]BL[380] ;W[dk]WL[499] ;B[im]BL[354] ;W[jm]WL[496] ;B[js]BL[340] ;W[is]WL[492] ;B[ks]BL[338] ;W[il]WL[598] ;B[ik]BL[335] ;W[hm]WL[597] ;B[gm]BL[333] ;W[im]WL[569] ;B[po]BL[578] ;W[on]WL[558] ;B[pp]BL[572] ;W[qo]WL[556] ;B[nq]BL[569] ;W[mh]WL[551] ;B[ng]BL[565] ;W[lg]WL[534] ;B[nk]BL[560] ;W[sm]WL[524] ;B[sl]BL[554] ;W[mn]WL[521] ;B[ln]BL[547] ;W[sn]WL[516] ;B[rl]BL[544] ;W[ld]WL[504] ;B[me]BL[538] ;W[kd]WL[484] ;B[md]BL[509] ;W[fk]WL[476] ;B[fl]BL[507] ;W[id]WL[468] ;B[en]BL[472] ;W[fe]WL[451] ;B[ff]BL[448] ;W[cc]WL[447] ;B[dd]BL[444] ;W[bd]WL[441] ;B[cd]BL[441] ;W[bb]WL[434] ;B[cb]BL[435] ;W[ac]WL[429] ;B[bc]BL[429] ;W[fc]WL[402] ;B[fd]BL[403] ;W[cc]WL[398] ;B[db]BL[396] ;W[se]WL[320] ;B[sf]BL[393] ;W[sd]WL[317] ;B[rf]BL[383] ;W[ds]WL[294] ;B[kk]BL[376] ;W[kl]WL[284] ;B[al]BL[360] ;W[ai]WL[595] ;B[]BL[317] ;W[]WL[595] ;B[]BL[317]C[ oca 12k : oca dead @ F15 yasuinooka 11k : yasuinooka dead @ A2 yasuinooka 11k : yasuinooka dead @ G12 oca 12k : oca dead @ F17 oca 12k : oca dead @ B16 oca 12k : oca dead @ C17 oca 12k : oca dead @ B18 oca 12k : oca dead @ A17 oca 12k : oca dead @ R8 yasuinooka done oca 12k : Thx for the game ] ;TW[ia][ja][ka][la][na][oa][pa][qa][ra][sa][jb][pb][qb][rb][sb][ic][sc][ah][bh][dh][gh][jh][kh][lh][ci][di][ei][fi][gi][li][gj][io][ro][so][ip][rp][sp][bq][iq][qq][rq][sq][ar][hr][ir][pr][rr][sr][as][bs][hs][ps][qs][rs][ss]TB[aa][ba][ca][da][ea][ab][bb][eb][ac][bc][cc][ec][fc][ad][bd][ed][nd][od][ce][de][ee][fe][ge][ne][oe][pe][qe][nf][of][pf][qg][rg][sg][qh][rh][sh][ri][si][rj][sj][qk][rk][sk][ql][em][fm][dn][fn][do][eo][fo][lo][ep][lp][mp][np][eq][lq][mq][lr][mr][ls][ms]OS[]) (;B[ar]C[This is the vital point. White can still live but will lose two stones] (;W[br] ;B[am] ;W[aq] ;B[bp] ;W[as] ;B[ao]) (;W[bq] ;B[am] (;W[ao]C[mistake] ;B[aq]) (;W[es]C[situational solution] ;B[fs] ;W[br] ;B[ao] ;W[as] ;B[bs] ;W[aq]C[Hard to find though in a real game!])))) (;B[li] ;W[ki] ;B[kj]C[A snapback is looming
White is in dire straits] ;W[kl]C[If White connects] ;B[jo]C[Black think of killing the whole group] ;W[in] ;B[ip] ;W[hp] ;B[gr] ;W[hr] ;B[il]C[It's hard for White to find two eyes])) (;B[nb]C[This is sente] (;W[gc] ;B[pb]C[dead]) (;W[pb] ;B[hd]C[This is much better compared to the game.]))) (;B[pb] ;W[qb] ;B[ob]LB[qa:3][ra:2][sb:1][sd:4]TR[qj]C[After this, White is left with a bulky five eyeshape in the corner. If he takes the vital point 1 then 2 threatens to remove the eyeshape but after 3, 4 kills.
So the only way White can live here is by breaking through the encirclement.
Thanks to the presence of the marked stone, it is hard for White to do so.] (;W[qe] ;B[rf]SQ[qj]C[Black's marked stone makes things easier.]) (;W[rf] ;B[qe] ;W[se] ;B[qg]TR[qj]C[Again, the marked stone comes in handy.])))
Re: OCA's log
Posted: Wed Apr 15, 2015 9:21 am
by oca
Thanks a lot Knotwilg ,
I will try to improve my playing reagarding to small gaps, I remember that Edlee allready mentioned that on some of my earlier games... I will try to replay the splitting sequence (66-82) against my self and see if I can do better...
Re: OCA's log
Posted: Wed Apr 15, 2015 12:32 pm
by mitsun
oca wrote:I will try to replay the splitting sequence (66-82) against my self and see if I can do better...
If you want a suggestion or hint:
At move 67, you came back to play the hanging connection at K9. This is a necessary and good move. It is also sente, since W will answer below to avoid being enclosed. Suppose you play this exchange a move earlier, without first pushing at J11. Now see how many more options you have above -- J12, J13, K12 for example are all more likely to enclose W than the game move J11, which forces W to squeeze out and escape. And if your reading says none of those moves actually work, then maybe consider head-butting the W stone at K15 or pushing through L17 to build extra strength before coming back to the primary attack.
To pursue the "squeezing through narrow gaps" idea a little more, suppose B plays something like K9 at move 65 and W decides the group below is safe, but the group above needs to avoid being enclosed. Then playing H12 looks like a reasonable and good move for W. After that, would B want to play J11? Surely that would be a slow and inefficient move after W already has a stone at H12. But with a different move order, this is what actually happened. Once your opponent successfully squeezes through the gap, your nearby stones are likely to end up on dame and become inefficient.
Re: OCA's log
Posted: Fri Apr 17, 2015 9:41 am
by oca
mitsun wrote: At move 67, you came back to play the hanging connection at K9. ... Suppose you play this exchange a move earlier...
I'm happy as I found this one before reading your comments... but then I got lost in a lot of variations...
On game 1, at H5 (followed by black G4, W-F4, black connect, white E5. Then if black cut at F3 you give atari at E3 and damage severely his corner.
Re: OCA's log
Posted: Sun May 03, 2015 5:49 am
by oca
Bki wrote:On game 1, at H5 (followed by black G4, W-F4, black connect, white E5. Then if black cut at F3 you give atari at E3 and damage severely his corner.
Thank you Bki, I played too fast, I was sure I can eat sthe stone like in a net, but missed that when he played H5, that would put my two stones in atari... very basic... but I still missed that
Re: OCA's log
Posted: Mon May 04, 2015 10:52 am
by mitsun
I would say you lost the second game because you played too many loose attacking and invading moves and never took the time to secure your positions with good thick defensive moves.
At the start, seems needlessly aggressive. Why jump into an area where you are already pincered and have no room to make a base? The right side is more open and larger. Letting W make a shimari here is not something you have to go to extreme measures to prevent.
The sequence to to left B with a glaring weakness at N2 -- if W plays there, B will have no base or eye-shape, while W will be making territory on both sides. W has already successfully punished the premature invasion. Instead of , which as you point out is an overplay, just defend calmly at N2 or M2. The game is still playable for B at this point.
is a very nice invasion, making use of the B thickness to the right, to get compensation for the loss on the side. The game is by no means lost yet. In fact, if you kill the corner, the game looks won -- try counting territories and see if you agree.
is again overly aggressive. Surely continuing the attack on the lower left corner to consolidate your gain there is much more important than starting an uncertain new fight in the center. After a surrounding move like F5, the W corner looks nearly dead. Even if W can live, playing here first guarantees sealing W in sente, for a very good local result. Or if you think W can live, attacking at G2 is an alternative, planning to drive W out, letting you naturally make side territory around C8. Either way B still has a good game.
Re: OCA's log
Posted: Tue May 05, 2015 11:27 am
by oca
Thanks a lot for your comments mitsun !
I play mostly on 9x9 these days, I wonder if that gave me some bad habits and if I became too aggressiv and maybe too ... "local thinking" on the 9x9 every thing is a battle...(or maybe not... but that's my perception from my level)