Life In 19x19

I played a game today in which my opponent made a bad move, paused 5 seconds or so and then requested an undo. My general policy is to never accept an undo unless it is an obvious misclick, so I refused his request. He ended up resigning and letting me know he was upset with me.

I had a little bit of guilt about doubting thee trust between players, but it didn't last long. I never request an undo even in the case of the most outrageous misclicks, so my policy towards myself is more strict than towards others. I was curious what others made of this and what balance they make between generosity of spirit and guarding against being taken advantage of.

I couldn't figure a way to incorporate it into the poll well, but I am especially interested in what conditions you will request an undo compared to the conditions in which you will grant one.

I'll accept a misclick undo, and I'll take my opponent's word for it. It's a game, and life's too short for me to quibble on trust stuff. If he says something like "oh, wait, that doesn't work" and then requests an undo, I might refuse though

I'm usually willing to allow undos, as long as they are reasonable.

I did refuse once, though. It was a long time ago, at a lower level...I had just captured a group, and the opponent asked for an undo. I expected him to tenuki, instead of adding another stone to the doomed group, as he had before, but he immediately asked for another undo. I told him that I didn't mind him fixing a misclick or mistake, but I wasn't going to let him rewind the game five moves. He complained, then, that there was no point in his playing any more, since he would lose. He probably eventually resigned. I no longer remember.

Fixing misclicks is fine with me, and I don't even mind very much if someone wants to just take back a bad move, as long as they don't go overboard to pretend it was a misclick when it was obviously not.

I'm going to be a troll ... what if it is a live in-person game? what then people? what then??!?!?!


**edit** sorry I couldn't help myself

Araban wrote:

Code: Select all

if it won't affect the outcome of the game:
  ok undo
else:
  if opponent's rank < my rank or my opponent didn't say hi back or my opponent already asked for undo:
    no undo
  else:
    ok undo

I like the if else programmer logic.

Jordus wrote:I'm going to be a troll ... what if it is a live in-person game? what then people? what then??!?!?!


**edit** sorry I couldn't help myself

I have accidentally placed a stone on an intersection I didn't intend to in an in-person tournament before, giving myself an empty triangle instead of cutting off my opponent's dying group. I don't know what to say apart from "It happens. Get over it."

I'll give an undo as long as I haven't gone yet; I figure then it's like DGS where you can play a move and then hit cancel as many times as you like before submitting it. If I've gone already, then no undo. If something is an obvious misclick then I'll pause to give them time to request undo. On the other hand, I wouldn't request an undo unless it was a game-ruining obvious misclick, but I would request undo then just to offer my opponent the satisfaction of winning by outplaying me without the assistance of misclicks, if they want it. I wouldn't grumble if they decided to say no though, I just think it's fair to see if they were enjoying the game and want to finish it without a misclick changing everything.

Jordus wrote:I'm going to be a troll ... what if it is a live in-person game? what then people? what then??!?!?!


**edit** sorry I couldn't help myself

As trollish as you were trying to be, I can't help myself thinking "meh, I'd probably allow that as well"

topazg wrote:

Jordus wrote:I'm going to be a troll ... what if it is a live in-person game? what then people? what then??!?!?!


**edit** sorry I couldn't help myself

As trollish as you were trying to be, I can't help myself thinking "meh, I'd probably allow that as well"

In a tournament it would not be permitted and in a casual game you are probably playing with a friend and so would allow it.

Depends. Like so many things in Go, there are so many exceptions and special cases. Such as:

• Teaching games with novices.
• Very casual games with friends.
• Opponent's overall attitude, etiquette, and demeanor.
• Obvious misclicks, e.g. 1-1.

For me, it just depends on my mood.

Undo is like giving to charity. It might make you feel warm inside, but I don't feel guilty if I don't give.

If I am walking into the store, and some beggar asks for change, if I feel OK, maybe I'll give it to him. But if I don't feel like it, I'll say no.

If that beggar then proceeds to try to make me feel bad or guilty, I don't appreciate it.

If you are a beggar - well, that's your prerogative. But if you're going to complain about it, I'd prefer you just got a job - or a decent mouse.

EdLee wrote:Depends. Like so many things in Go, there are so many exceptions and special cases. Such as:

[list]
[*]Teaching games with novices.

Ha ha ha--when playng the kids in the Go club, I often ORDER them to take a terrible move back. It seems to take them a while to get over wanting to play in tiger's mouths.

I remember this one player kept asking for undos, and I granted them all because it's a small thing to make someone happy, and then I made a rare misclick in the same game and asked for an undo to correct the mistake, and the guy refused.

Five minutes later he asked for yet another undo and I let him have another, again. Pretty much sums up my policy.

Generally, I grant any and all undo requests, regardless of context.