Life In 19x19

A humble suggestion, which I'd much appreciate when you get around to it if it's simple to implement:

None of the "view" buttons are quite what I want. I just want "view recent posts," which is exactly what the view new posts button gets you if you aren't logged in (minus the "new to me" symbols which I get by being logged in).

In case you want to know why I like this sort of list: Mainly I like this because I want to see new posts, but I like static lists and sometimes go back to previous posts. I can already see which ones are unread by me by whether they have the "new" symbol next to them. I also sometimes switch devices and like the same list to show up on the next device as opposed to the list being cleared. The "view unread posts" button doesn't quite do it for me because sometimes I stop before the end of a thread and may go back to it, and seeing it in the same list helps me remember it and find it (some sort of visual memory seems to be relevant here, and in fact I think it's easier for me to find even unread posts that I noticed in a previous pass and wanted to look at later in a "view recent posts" list due to this).

If there's a way to do this already, I'd of course appreciate being told how.

+1

Imo, this should replace "View active topics."

Yes, I have tried "View active topics" as an alternative to "View new posts" to find recent topics that I have read, and I have not found it to be of much help.

On second thought, not "view recent posts," but rather "view recently updated (threads)" is what I would most like to have. This way, the list wouldn't get filled by all the posts from one hyperactive thread.

daal wrote:On second thought, not "view recent posts," but rather "view recently updated (threads)" is what I would most like to have. This way, the list wouldn't get filled by all the posts from one hyperactive thread.

I agree. The slight error in terminology has already occurred with "view unread posts" etc.

I want a list of every thread that has posts that I haven't read, ordered most recently updated first.

Each entry in the list should have 5 fields:
1) The name of the thread,
2) A number indicating how many unread posts are in that thread,
3) A clickable link to the first post.
4) A checkbox, such that if I check it, the unread posts in that thread are marked as read, and that thread does not appear on my list again unless more posts are added.
5) A second checkbox, such that if I check it, the thread never appears on my list again, regardless of additional posts.

Joaz Banbeck wrote:I want a list of every thread that has posts that I haven't read, ordered most recently updated first.

Each entry in the list should have 5 fields:
1) The name of the thread,
2) A number indicating how many unread posts are in that thread,
3) A clickable link to the first post.
4) A checkbox, such that if I check it, the unread posts in that thread are marked as read, and that thread does not appear on my list again unless more posts are added.
5) A second checkbox, such that if I check it, the thread never appears on my list again, regardless of additional posts.

View new posts gives you a list of threads with posts you haven't read and it is ordered most recently updated first. This list also includes: 1) the name of the thread and 3) a clickable link to the first post (as well as one to the first updated post). Clicking on the link has basically the same function as 4).

Considering the fact that you are an admin and could presumably make such changes additions yourself if you were serious about it, I assume that your wishlist is to be taken as sarcasm. If not, my apologies, but if so, I would like to re-iterate that a "view recently updated" link would help users find a post that they had recently read and would like to read again, perhaps to comment on, whether or not they have been updated in the meantime, saving them the trouble of digging through the 36 forums to find it again.

daal wrote:Considering the fact that you are an admin and could presumably make such changes additions yourself ...

there are different level of admins

some are programming level admins, while others are only moderator level admins.

daal wrote:View new posts gives you a list of threads with posts you haven't read and it is ordered most recently updated first. This list also includes: 1) the name of the thread and 3) a clickable link to the first post (as well as one to the first updated post). Clicking on the link has basically the same function as 4).

You mean view unread posts. View new posts includes threads that have been updated since your last visit (or something like that), so it doesn't include older unread posts. (Also, it does include threads you've already read if you e.g. hit refresh.)

The functionality Joaz asks for isn't what I'm interested in, but it sounds like something some people might like and it sounds like the request was made in earnest. The key suggestion is 5, which I guess is akin to the "mark malkovich read" button but for individual threads ad infinitum. (You can do 4 yourself with two operations: middle click to open it in a background tab, then close that tab; or click the link then hit back.)

daal wrote:I assume that your wishlist is to be taken as sarcasm.

Sorry about this. I was having a grumpy day. I wasn't meaning to insult your ability to write sarcastically.

xed_over wrote:

daal wrote:Considering the fact that you are an admin and could presumably make such changes additions yourself ...

there are different level of admins

some are programming level admins, while others are only moderator level admins.

Thanks, but not quite true. TTBOMK, all admins except Arkhamking are the same level. We an informal allocation of responsibilities amongst equals based on inclination rather than level. I do have access to the code, but I have never written a line of PHP in my life. I could try to make these changes, but I choose not to do so because at least 3 other admins have experience with PHP. OTOH, several of them have no taste for the non-technical admin duties.

Someday, maybe Fwiffo will decide to do modding and I'll decide to update code. Then you are all doomed!

@Daal: No problem. It was a reasonable interpretation.

daal wrote:...
View new posts gives you a list of threads with posts you haven't read...

No, it doesn't. I am not sure exactly what it does, but it is not that. ( I suspect that there is some age cut-off )

For example, I just clicked on 'View new posts'. I got a list of 11 posts. One of those was a Malkovich game. I then checked the 1-on-1 Malkovich forum. I started counting the ones that are marked unread, and quit after a dozen.

I think that 'view new posts' is actually 'view recent posts'. What I want is 'view all posts new to me'.

I'm confused. It sure sounds like Joaz wants "view unread posts" with options for customization + number of new posts in a thread since he last viewed it.

As for "view new posts" it works in an extremely odd way. When you're logged in, it shows both unread and read posts, and it's sensitive to when you last logged in. So it's not like unread posts, but it also doesn't seem to just show posts that are after a certain time.

If you log in infrequently and immediately look at "view new posts", it approximates "view unread posts".

Joaz Banbeck wrote:I think that 'view new posts' is actually 'view recent posts'. What I want is 'view all posts new to me'.

Have you tried view unread posts? It's what you asked for minus the fancy features.

As for what I want: view new posts is frequently cleared. If you're not logged in (so there's no record of how recently you last were here or something), there are currently 40 pages of threads when you click on "view new posts"; namely all threads ordered by how recently they were updated. I want that, but when I'm logged in.

prokofiev wrote: view new posts is frequently cleared. If you're not logged in (so there's no record of how recently you last were here or something), there are currently 40 pages of threads when you click on "view new posts"; namely all threads ordered by how recently they were updated. I want that, but when I'm logged in.

The way view new posts works is that it only shows the new posts since your last login. The 40 page thing actually was found by accident by using the user view new post but without a specific login id attached when querying the sql server. I'm not sure about how to do it when a user is logged in but I'll look into it when i can.