Bantari wrote:Kirby wrote:Bantari wrote:Completely disagree.
...
IMO, age might be a factor. Kids may be more harmed by rote memorization of joseki than adults, because I think they learn differently.
Well... in general, you are probably right.
But - getting exposed to a few of the the 3-4 move sequences which constitute the basic josekis I am thinking of - I would not call that 'rote memorization'. Its more like a direction-giver or idear-jumpstarter, something like that. It was of great value to me as a beginner, and I think other beginners might benefit greatly as well.
PS>
I think this all touches on another thing we have not really defined in this context: what do we mean by 'learning joseki'?
Might be a good place to start, or it may happen we are talking about different things here.
My own thought on this is that it makes sense to use standard joseki to illustrate basic ideas for beginners. How to surround an invasion, how to avoid being sealed in by an approach move, how to take away the base of an approach stone with a pincer... there is no sense in not using the joseki as demonstrations. But if you're not encouraging people to remember and replay specific moves, then I don't think of it as "learning joseki".