I'm going to pick the game controls that the last one had, because everyone seemed happy enough with that. If there are objections and suggestions to change, please add them to thread - if enough people suggest something else, we can vote on it:
Ruleset - AGA attracted a few positive comments, and may as well be the default. Others are fine if agreed by both players.
Main Time - 40 minutes.
Overtime - Either 10 stones in 5 minutes Canadian overtime or 5 x 0:40 Japanese Byo-yomi is fine. If there is a disagreement between players, the Canadian overtime is the over-riding default.
Handicaps - All games to be played at handicap-2 (so 3k vs 7k is at 2 stones), komi is 7 if even, 0 if no komi or handicap.
Tournament format
Initially I'll do seeded group stages, with each seed group randomly distributed. I don't know what size groups we are likely to have, but probably around 6 if I can manage it. Each group I was envisaging would be a single round robin, with games to be completed within a single calendar month - probably May, but it depends on whether we get plenty of people signed up, we could always start mid-April and give a month and a half for games.
At the end of the first group stage, I was envisaging a second stage, and if we wanted the top two players in the top group in the second stage could play a best of 3 for the "hahn-title" or something. An example would be 24 people signing up, being split into 4 groups of 6 players. Top 2 go into a top group of 8, next to go into a middle group of 8, and bottom 2 into a bottom group of 8 (so we can rank 1st - 24th if that appeals).
I'm very happy with only the top two progressing, but I thought it might be a positive thing to allow all the players to play plenty of games - in this case, there would be 13 games per player spread over 2 months.
Scoring system
Hahn - 50 points for jigo. 60-40 for 1-9 point win. 70-30 for 10-19 point win. 80-20 for 20-29 point win. 90-10 for 30-39 point win. 100-0 for 40+ point win or resignation.
Simplified - 50 points for jigo. +1 point to the winner (and -1 to the loser) for each point, with 50+ points being 100-0
Herman - 5 points for jigo. log scale, so 1 point win = 6-4, 3 points = 7-3, 7 points = 8-2, 15 points = 9-1, and 31+ points = 10-0. These aren't thresholds, and I'll track fractional points to 2 DP.
The advantage of the Herman system is that the closer the game is, the more important each point is. The downside is that the less close the game is, the less the points matter when the game isn't close. Six of one, half a dozen of the other
Signing up - Please read!!
So, for signing up, can people please entering rank, preferred server, preferred scoring system, and whether you'd prefer a second group stage regardless of finishing position, or just for the top players in each group (additional weight will be given to the choices of kyu players here, for obvious reasons). Also, preferred existence of a title match at the end.
To start the ball rolling:
topazg - 1d
KGS
Herman scoring
Second stage for all players
Title match for top two - best of 3
Currently registered (21 confirmed)
ez4u - 3d - A
Shaddy - 3d - A
topazg - 1d - A
koosh - 1d - A
daniel - 1k - B
stable - 1k - B
redundant - 1k - B
mw42 - 2k - B
kirby - 3k - C
entropi - 4k - C
oren - 5k - C
CSamurai - 5k - C
Tofu - 6k - D
phillip18 - 7k - D
Cyclops - 7k - D
Phelan - 7k - D
Mnemonic - 8k - E
Jordus - 8k - E
S1NK - 11k - E
hailthorn011 - 11k - E
LucianoS - 11k - E
Letters represent seed brackets
Server: KGS 12
Scoring: Herman 5 - Simplified 0 (2) - Hahn 1 (3)
Second stage: Yes 10 - No 0
Title match: Yes 9 - Best of 3 with 4 votes - even number of games with 3 votes
Last updated stats at post: LucianoS
Addendum: 1 comment on a preference for Japanese Byo-yomi
