Life In 19x19

BigDoug wrote:You can do this today by creating a private room.

Will you make it permanent?

BigDoug wrote:You can do this today by creating a private room. Admins don't monitor private rooms.

It isn't really an anarchy room if people have to ask permission to enter...

speedchase wrote:

BigDoug wrote:You can do this today by creating a private room. Admins don't monitor private rooms.

It isn't really an anarchy room if people have to ask permission to enter...

The most important is that a real anarchist owns the room. I guess I could be the right. I would let enter only people that behave like real anarchists should behave. This will also ensure that anarchy works as desired.

asura wrote:

speedchase wrote:

BigDoug wrote:You can do this today by creating a private room. Admins don't monitor private rooms.

It isn't really an anarchy room if people have to ask permission to enter...

The most important is that a real anarchist owns the room. I guess I could be the right. I would let enter only people that behave like real anarchists should behave. This will also ensure that anarchy works as desired.

But if they are to follow your rule about no rules are they still really anarchists or just some form of libertarian?

Boidhre wrote:But if they are to follow your rule about no rules are they still really anarchists or just some form of libertarian?

I think that was the joke.

speedchase wrote:

Boidhre wrote:But if they are to follow your rule about no rules are they still really anarchists or just some form of libertarian?

I think that was the joke.

...

asura wrote:

BigDoug wrote:You can do this today by creating a private room.

Will you make it permanent?

Check with me when we're both on-line next time and I'll see what I can do.

speedchase wrote:

BigDoug wrote:You can do this today by creating a private room. Admins don't monitor private rooms.

It isn't really an anarchy room if people have to ask permission to enter...

I'd actually argue the opposite. You won't ask permission of the room owner to enter. You'll DEMAND to be let in. The fellow anarchist will be impressed by your lack of eloquence and therefore has to let you in. Then you can both start smashing the place up.

But why would they smash the place up? Being that it is a private room, there won't be anybody to see them. What is the point of being a violent anarchist if nobody is watching?

Joaz Banbeck wrote:But why would they smash the place up? Being that it is a private room, there won't be anybody to see them. What is the point of being a violent anarchist if nobody is watching?

Hehe... I was wondering when somebody would make this point, ever since I made the suggestion.
The response will show what iit is all about: freedom or audience.

BigDoug wrote:

asura wrote:

BigDoug wrote:You can do this today by creating a private room.

Will you make it permanent?

Check with me when we're both on-line next time and I'll see what I can do.

Oh, I was just kidding. I read somewhere admins hate this question and always answer it with "no"

Thank you, it's really a nice offer!

Anyhow, I already do everything on KGS that I want and had so far no problems.

Also a private anarchy room would have a hard time to become big enough to be an attractive choice. To make it more attractive it would be necessary to restrict the freedom in all other rooms. The most effective reason to move there would be to restrict the allowed josekis

asura wrote:Also a private anarchy room would have a hard time to become big enough to be an attractive choice. To make it more attractive it would be necessary to restrict the freedom in all other rooms. The most effective reason to move there would be to restrict the allowed josekis

I don't see why you need to restrict or change anything in the other rooms.

Just create a private room, in which you can curse, be vulgar, and talk in foreign languages as much as you want. It does not even need to be permanent - each time you log in you can create in anew. Might be a bit of a hassle, but its a small price for freedom, I think.

If there is a friend you want to curse at, be vulgar to, or speak to in a foreign language - invite him to this private room - if he/she is in the mood, he will join. Again - full freedom to go there or to stay out! If you want a stranger to abuse - might cost you something, but I am sure pretty sure necessary services will appear. Supply always follows demand.

What's more - each of the people who needs some anarchy can create their own private bits of heaven and bask in their freedom of being rude or vulgar any time they chose! Or they can join somebody else's heaven - although this might not be a good idea, once the cursing starts in full, chances are the owner will boot the other guy (so much for 'no bans' I guess.)

Anyways - what's not perfect about that? Its like - full freedom on demand, for free, in private or communal - you chose!
Instant gratification on a silver platter with cherry on top.

Bantari wrote:

asura wrote:Also a private anarchy room would have a hard time to become big enough to be an attractive choice. To make it more attractive it would be necessary to restrict the freedom in all other rooms. The most effective reason to move there would be to restrict the allowed josekis

I don't see why you need to restrict or change anything in the other rooms.

I didn't mean that something should be restricted.
My point is that as long as I feel free enough on KGS I've no motivation to create an anarchy room.

Probably if it really would become necessary to create an anarchy room nobody would be allowed to create one.